[Local Flavor]:Die Yuan

By Derek Hafner, Feb 3rd, 2009 | In Dining



When discussing the city's local cuisine, non¨Clocals have the tendency to be disparaging in their criticism. Like the city itself, Shanghai's cuisine is an amalgamation of foreign cooking methods, with the most palpable flavors coming from Jiangsu and Zhejiang. Unlike the subtle flavoring of the dishes of those two provinces, Shanghai's cuisine is much more potent, and most complaints follow the same line -- the food is too sweet, uses too much rice wine, or is too oily.

Admittedly, a successful Shanghainese dish requires a careful balance. Shanghai food can be sweet, but a well-prepared dish is not overwhelming in its sweetness, and there's a thin line where just a small amount of sugar can change the edibility of a dish. Eating at a greasy spoon like Bao Luo is not a proper place to experience good Shanghainese food. These kinds of restaurants have neither the time nor the energy to make sure that, while trying to be innovative -- adding, say, sprinkles to a dish -- they won't overwhelm it with too much sweetness. With such a delicate balance of rich flavor necessary, it should be no surprise that many Shanghainese restaurants, in an attempt to quickly serve the masses, don't achieve that balance, and leave so many people with reason to criticize the food.

The real problem is that most people just haven't found the right restaurant.

Down the street from Xintiandi is a restaurant that avoids all of the mistakes that give Shanghainese cuisine a bad name. Die Yuan (the English name is Butterfly Garden, but the English sign is barely visible from the road) is the type of restaurant that makes a food lover happy to live in this city. The food here is 100% Shanghainese; while many other quality Shanghai restaurants are attempting (welcome) innovations to the genre, Die Yuan is a virtual map to the roots of Shanghai food.

Looking through the menu (available in English) you'll notice a lot of the dishes are Shanghai classics. On last visit, the server recommended three cold dishes (a lot for a three-person party). Lu Cai (³²Ë) is similar to the cucumber and garlic ubiquitous in Chinese restaurants, but they've added the texture of jellyfish slices (adds more crunch, not more taste). Shou si ji (ÊÖ˺¼¦) is dry, slightly salty shredded chicken. While seemingly plain, I felt it was great as a light dish before heading into the heavier sauces of the main dishes. The third cold dish was one of Shanghai's famous drunken dishes, zui mao xie (×íëз), drunken crab. I've had this in several restaurants before, but I've never been a fan, either because the crab didn't taste fresh or the rice wine it had been marinated in was of a low quality. Die Yuan was the first restaurant in which I've eaten more than one piece of the crab without the intention of being polite. The crab here was cut so that the roe was easily accessible, and the rice wine was good enough to drink.

The two specialties of the restaurant were new to me, but are apparently Shanghai staples: Shao zhi tang yu (ÉÕÖ­öðÓã) was served on a flaming plate that the waiter magically extinguishes. The fish, fried pomfret, was crispy and served in a tangy sauce that was sweet, but only lightly so -- not overwhelming as many expect from a Shanghainese sauce. The standout for me though was mian jing sai rou kao qing cai (Ãæ½îÈûÈ⿾Çà²Ë). Lion's head pork meatballs stuffed into fried tofu balls and served in a thick hong shao sauce with baby bok choy. This dish was the perfect balance of sweetness that comes from Shanghai's secret red sauce, with the added diversity of texture from a tough ball of fried tofu and the soft meatball inside.

Die Yuan's menu is a veritable guide to Shanghai cuisine. It's certainly not the first restaurant to establish itself as a purveyor of classic Shanghai cooking, but it deserves to be said in the same breathe as other Shanghai food institutions. Die Yuan does not have a single dish that makes it famous, it has a thorough, consistent menu instead, and it will leave foreigners remembering Shanghai as a city of great food, not food that's too sweet and oily.

In terms of prices, dinner for two including drinks should come out to around 250rmb.

E-Mail this article


Please sign in or register to E-Mail articles

GOODLIFE, Feb 9th, 2009

The food was crap. "Hong Shao Ro" was too sweet, "Shou Si Ji" was too dry. "Jiao Yian San Bei" was too Salty. Onion Noodles had no onion taste and had a sauce????..... Better to go to Lao Jishi if want good consistent Shanghainese food.

graceseanchang, Aug 28th, 2009

I really like this place. I had the "hong shao rou" as well and the cold chicken dish pictured above, as well as their black pepper iron plate pork, thousand year egg, and cold wild mountain vegetable, and all were good. Perhaps it was because I have un-refined American born Chinese taste, but I was there with two very picky boys (one American born Chinese, and one English born Chinese) and one other American born Chinese girl and they all loved the food. Total bill for dinner of four people with beers came out to about 320. Very affordable and tasty food. (and it's right next to the "wang ba" where we went to play dota afterwards :P)

Post a Comment
Signed in with: Not signed in


Please sign in or register to comment

MP3 Monday: Immanu El / Jorma

Feb 6th, 2012 by Morgan Short

Best Laid Plans: Part II

Feb 3rd, 2012 by Morgan Short

Best Laid Plans: Part I

Feb 2nd, 2012 by Morgan Short

MP3 Monday: Locals Spotlight

Jan 30th, 2012 by Morgan Short

All Nightlife Articles » All Articles »

  • Jan 31st, 2012 - Skeletons and the Closet
  • Jan 11th, 2012 - Ponderous Matters
  • Nov 9th, 2011 - Italo Just-Go
  • Oct 11th, 2011 - Worlds Apart
  • All of AskMatsume

    Hassle free ticket purchasing and delivery for Shanghai's cultural and concert events:


    Yo-Yo Ma & The Silk Road Ensemble

    March 7
    at Shanghai Grand Theatre


    David Garrett

    Feb 27
    at Shanghai Concert Hall


    IL DIVO in Shanghai

    Feb 28
    at Shanghai Grand Stage


    Formula 1 GP

    April 13-15
    at Shanghai International Circuit


    Roxette Back in China

    March 14
    at Shanghai Grand Stage


    Lacrimas Profundere: Goth Night

    March 1
    at Mao Livehouse


    HERRO! featuring Justin Martin

    Feb 17
    at The Waterhouse at South Bund


    Sven Väth

    Feb 18
    at Boom


    Westlife: Greatest Hits Farewell Tour

    Feb 25
    at Shanghai Grand Stage


    Calvin Harris

    Feb 17
    at G-Plus


    Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra

    Feb 16+17
    at Shanghai Oriental Art Center


    ERA

    Daily 7.30pm
    at Shanghai Circus World


    More on SmartTicket »