Secrets

By Christopher St Cavish, Aug 12th, 2009 | In Dining



I'm always trying to dig up new and better things to eat. My conversations tend to go like this: "Hey, how are you?" Them: "Blah blah blah" Me: "Right, cool, sounds nice... Eat anywhere good lately?"

Most people hold on to their secret spots in the face of my asking, thinking that by divulging them, they'll somehow be "ruined". It's an elitist and misplaced thought, tied up in fears about being able to get a seat and an idea that once some vague "others" get in, the quality's gonna take a nosedive. Think about it, man. Holding on to "secret" places doesn't make sense. For one, someone told you about it. Spread the love. For two, the situation -- tiny, unknown place; outstanding food; reservations gobbled up by a wave of customers -- hardly exists here. Half of the time, when I finally manage to extract the address of someone's special place, I show up to a busy restaurant. Even on the odd occasions where it might make selfish sense -- Maekawa, for example -- what's the point of hiding it? Too secretive, and your special place is going out of business.

I get the idea. I subscribed to it for a while, holding on to a handful of places that I didn't want you ruining. But I got over it. I tried to picture what a "ruined" restaurant looks like -- Di Shui Dong? Guyi? Both of those places have faults, but they've got a lot of positives, too, and they're going to be like that whether I'm going or you're going or half of Xuhui is going. When I realized I couldn't picture a "ruined" restaurant -- POOF! -- the fantasy evaporated, and then the whole idea revealed itself as the stupid and selfish maxim it is. Shanghai is not overflowing with enough spectacular restaurants and dishes. We gotta share, man, you know, let it all out.

So, I'm clearing house. I haven't held back on much over the years. This is all I've got. Have at 'em.

The Wild Game Place




I'm not sure if this joint has a name. Let's call it The Wild Game Place. Downstairs, it's an unassuming tea shop. Upstairs, there's an anteroom with guys playing mah-jongg for cash and two unspectacular private dining rooms serving wild game from Anhui. It's gotta be illegal and if you want in, you've gotta have someone vouch for you to the owner.

There's no menu here. You reserve a time and a number of people -- the number of chairs suggest six to ten -- and then show up to a plastic-lined table set like the one in the picture, overloaded with home-style Anhui cooking. On the night I went, it was a lot of braised, brown meat of questionable provenance. There was a muntjac stew, a tiny deer who, judging by the size of rib cage, wasn't much bigger than a kitten; slices of fried wild boar belly (pictured below); a hearty stew of badger and white radish; and a couple of dishes we couldn't identify. Braised for long periods of time and seasoned with soy sauce, garlic, and ginger, the differences in the game are obliterated. Mostly, it tastes like overcooked meat. The owner assured us that none of it was endangered, and for the 100rmb price tag, it seems unlikely it was, but in the same breath, let out that most of his twenty or so customers on a given night are gov't officials. Take that for what you will. They don't come for the chicken soup.



The owner is a plain-looking guy from the mountains of Anhui with a buzz-cut and a natural bent on food. All the game stuff is, I imagine, his bread-and-butter and a good way to curry favor with powerful people, but he started the joint as a way to keep eating the pure, fertilizer-free food of home. Now -- if you believe him -- he doesn't just have people bring him eggs, vegetables, and chickens from Anhui, but even the water he uses to brew a rough, green tea and cook the chicken soup. His groceries are carried by hand on the trains.

I've got no clue how the average person eats here. When I went, I tagged along with a friend who had an in, and this isn't the kind of place you can stroll in casually for dinner. Hell, I hardly remember where it was -- somewhere around the Dongchang Lu metro station area, north of Shiji Da Dao. Maybe look for a tea shop with a wire curlicue staircase in the back.

Maekawa


Maekawa is Sushi Oyama without white people. It's really only the Japanese who are cool with spending 800rmb on sushi and sashimi at a place whose name carries no cachet -- and Willy. That dude knows all the great Japanese spots.

Maekawa is a small space -- four private rooms, eight seats at the counter -- done up in traditional pale woods that hides out on the fourth floor of an unassuming block of Hongqiao Lu. It's as expensive as you want to get -- how much toro can you eat? -- but averages somewhere in the high hundreds for dinner. Occasionally, there are sea creatures here you won't see anywhere else -- Japanese fan lobsters, with the beautifully sweet flesh of a langoustine, for example -- and a standard in the kitchen that sets it apart from other Japanese places around town. There is a menu, but you're probably better off just telling the staff what you wanna spend and letting them work it out for you. Gotta speak a bit of the Chinese or Japanese for this one, for sure.

Laifood 99


Hong Kong has/had that thing with private restaurants, the ones in people's homes, but Shanghai never really picked up on that. Laifood 99 is the only one I know of, and it's hiding in plain sight on the western end of Fuxing Xi Lu. Before Boxing Cat and all their rabble-rousing moved in, the quiet stretch's most prominent neighbor was probably Marrakech. Laifood 99, also called Fuxing 99, is a few doors down, towards Yongfu Lu. This powder-blue guy right here.



Frankly, it's not all that special. The Deco-era building is cool, but the interior is done up in heavy Shanghainese style, with floral sofas in the six private rooms -- Laifood 99 is private-rooms only -- and a distinct grandma vibe about the place. Also, it's musty as hell. You can almost smell the mold growing underneath all that rose-patterned wallpaper on the first floor.



The whole place seems styled after the Fu family of restaurants (this and this), which is a good starting point. Fu 1088 is my favorite Shanghainese place in town. But both Fu restaurants do the nostalgic Shanghai villa thing much better, with great restoration, a heap of elegance, and a precise kitchen. Laifood 99, on the other hand, might have a chef from Fu 1039, cooking almost-there upscale Shanghainese cuisine, but the paint is chipped and the wallpaper is peeling. Leave this one's hairy crab specialties and foie gras dishes where they belong -- with gov't officials and aging businessmen.

The Cheap Avocado




The cheap avocado is the holy grail of expat shopping, right? Here's where you get 'em, ten kuai a piece: 274 Wulumuqi Lu, just south of Wuyuan Lu, next to the duck neck place. You wouldn't know it from the exterior loaded with amaranth, lotus root, radish, and all kinds of other things that are not good in guacamole, but Mrs. Jiang has been slinging expat-food for a while now. Ask for basil and she pulls out a many-kilo bag of the fresh stuff, followed by a string of questions, mostly in English: Pine nuts? (She has two types.) Fresh mozzarella? (Made in Jiading, not half bad, 17rmb per bag.) Mint? Smoked salmon? (Norwegian, frozen, 50rmb per jin.) Chicken breasts? (Frozen, 10rmb per jin.) Anchovies? (Tinned, 12rmb a pop.) Tuna? (Frozen, 50rmb per jin.) She's got red wine vinegar and canned chickpeas and shallots, too. At the moment, she even has some lovely "organic" blueberries from Qingdao, 12rmb per half-pint. Take your burnet and sorrel and stuff it, City Shop.

Tagged: Avocado Lady

E-Mail this article


Please sign in or register to E-Mail articles

bottledpoetry, Aug 12th, 2009

Nice recommendations :) I must pay a visit to the avocado lady!

firedancer, Aug 12th, 2009

i have to check it out she must have a mexican supplier......guacamole time. City Super watch out 10RMb for avocado not bad ha!

Aquarius , Aug 12th, 2009

I go there all the time (veggie shop) !! Cheap and fresh veggie. Nice people at the shop. They know the name of veg in English so that made my life easier !!!

iamnothere, Aug 12th, 2009

Oh, thanks for the cheap avocado tip! Must go. There is also a kiosk in the wet market on TaiKang Lu that always has fresh mint, basil, cilantro, arugula, rosemary, galangal (thai ginger) and even fresh thyme and sage on occasion.

subdivide, Aug 14th, 2009

looking at veg lady's photos makes me homesick for Wulumqi Lu!

gfunk, Aug 14th, 2009

Great summation of Laifood 99. But, you underplayed the utterly raped interior of this deco gem. I almost fell to my knees and wept when I finally got to step inside. Like painting the inside of a Chippendale cabinet with Dulux 'Radiant Peach'. Still my favourite deco exterior. *sniff*

RandyStevens, Aug 16th, 2009

Maekawa is very good, but Sushi Oyama is still the benchmark. The toro at Maekawa is not as sweet, the beef not as tender, and the non sushi/sashimi stuff not as inspired. It is still a very good food experience, and the sake was excellent but Sushi Oyama is still the real deal for me...

jliu921, Aug 20th, 2009

Maekawa isn't very good. That's an understatement. To even be compared to Sushi Oyama, is a flagrant insult to the quality and dedication that Oyama represents. I'd hate to say this Christopher Cavish, but... SmartShanghai should refund anyone that went to Maekawa with expectations higher than that of a 199rmb all you can eat all you can drink all you can throw up afterwards dinner. That may be a bit harsh, but let's review: Ambience and decor was nice, that of a most Gubei mid-high end ranged restaurants. Places like Misato, Yuzhang, all come to mind. (Granted they have better food).

700 RMB set course ( They most expensive set course ) - btw, about the same price as Oyama.
The first two appetizers were decent, bonito flakes with spinach and a peanutty fermented tofu with wasabi. Then disappointment hit. The sashimi plate came. The mackerel was fishy, the flounder was cut too thick and quite frankly very roughly. The otoro was watery and sinewy. You get better toro at the korean Tuna house on Shuichenglu in peace plaza...

The next fish noodle soup was mediocre at best, but at least I didn't want to gag.. The Yakimono platter really made me want to leave the restaurant right then and there. (All of the items on the plate were premade and cold. Two pieces of cat food broiled fish were served with a broiled hodgepodge of fish and mashed vegetables with a starch product. If I remember correctly, A plain egg / unagi roll was served with that as well. You could get this at Haizhixin(All you can eat crap buffet). Thats how bad it was. (Their attempt at a broiled fish over a fish cake I think) They then ran out of their main event (matsusaka beef). Btw I was there at 7:30. So apparently the Japanese speaking customers took priority over us. Regardless they replaced it with supposed Japanese imported oysters that were so fish that my friend almost threw up. The next course was a disaster of an attempt at Tempura. Overly oily and heavy. They paired good quality ingredients without evaluating the flavor profiles that would result. Matsutake mushrooms and snow crab leg meat. You couldn't even taste the crab. It was a waste.

Here's the kicker. The Temakis they served were soggy. The waitress tried to excuse it by saying that happens when they put rice inside seaweed. I agree after you leave it sitting there for 5 minutes before bringing it to the table. I almost forgot to mention how slow the service was. 20-30 minutes between our vegetable appetizer and our first course. "They were busy."

Of course by this time I was trying to wash my mouth out with hot tea. Unfortunately, they came by once to fill our tea all night. I had to ask for it that time. To all of our dismay the single possible saving grace that came as our last main course was terrible. Soggy Ikura and Uni nigiri. The unagi sushi was overcooked and made so badly that pieces were flaking off onto the plate. The kanpachi looked old and dry and YELLOW. The tuna was sinewy again. The shrimp also looked like it had been sitting out with the skin starting to shrivel.

Of course all of this could be maybe be redeemed by an excellent fish bone soup or hamaguri soup. No... we were served watery, bland miso soup.

In their defense, after all of the bad service and overpriced repugnant food, the owner and manager did come and apologize for the quality tonight.

We won't be returning any time soon. Oyama, we'll see you soon.

Chris, take a crash course on good Japanese food from Oyama sometime. You'll benefit from it.

EWang, Aug 20th, 2009

I expected high quality toro, uni, and imported beef from Japan. In exchange for my 700RMB I received 3 prostrated members of the staff: owner, head chef, and manager, apologizing for the exceptionally slow service, mediocre food, and a badly tempered air-conditioning unit, with the attention span of an ADD afflicted redheaded step-child. One moment on full blast 16C, and then 30 minutes of inactivity with us sweltering in the humidity and our sushi, sashimi, and handrolls becoming liquified messes.

Let's not talk about the yakimono...I didn't know cat food was on the menu.

The main course for the 700RMB set meal is a beef centerpiece. 7:30pm it's sold out. What happened? It must have sold out while we waited 25-30 minutes for our 2nd course. Perhaps speaking Japanese is a pre-requisite to obtain this exclusive dish.

Oysters.... fishy, NOT ON ICE, monumentally large bivalve. The size of a calf's tongue. It was distracting and daunting to say the least. End result: diarrhea...twice.

Oyama, here I come.

RandyStevens, Aug 24th, 2009

Wow - what you guys describe about Maekawa sounds incredible. I was there with some very experienced Sushi lovers and we all know how this stuff should taste from many visits to Japan. It did not match Oyama, but everything was good, fresh, prepared well, and the staff was very friendly (Chinese staff and Japanese sushi chef), even handing out 1 year anniversary gifts. I am sorry to hear that you had such a hard time there, but to be fair I have to say that I did not experience any of your horror stories at Maekawa.

Post a Comment
Signed in with: Not signed in


Please sign in or register to comment

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Apr 10th, 2012 - Obsessions
  • Feb 29th, 2012 - Days of Not Hard Nights
  • Jan 31st, 2012 - Skeletons and the Closet
  • Jan 11th, 2012 - Ponderous Matters
  • All of AskMatsume

    Hassle free ticket purchasing and delivery for Shanghai's cultural and concert events:

    Glasvegas

    May 17
    at Mao Livehouse


    ERA

    Daily 7.30pm
    at Shanghai Circus World



    Brawl on the Bund

    June 2
    at Kerry Hotel


    Friendly Fires

    May 22
    at Mao Livehouse


    Joss Stone

    May 23
    at Shanghai Grand Stage


    Steve Aoki

    June 3
    at G-Plus


    Art on Ice

    May 26, 27
    at Mercedes-Benz Arena


    More on SmartTicket »